Human Rights
Ukrainian soldiers in Russia maintain 'polite and discreet coexistence' with locals
Ukraine says it controls about 100 border settlements over an area of about 1,000 sq. km -- a humiliation for Russian President Vladimir Putin.
By Kontur and AFP |
KYIV -- Ukrainian soldiers who stormed into Kursk province, Russia, in August show no signs of leaving.
The "several thousand" Russian civilians still living in territory occupied by Ukrainian forces are mostly elderly and largely cut off from the outside world, with no electricity or phone network, according to Ukrainian forces.
Ukrainian troops deployed as part of Kyiv's shock offensive into Kursk province, Russia, told AFP of a "coexistence" with the locals, despite initial mistrust from residents exposed to Russian state media portrayals of Ukrainians as "monsters."
The incursion, two and a half years after Moscow invaded Ukraine, is the first time a foreign army has entered Russia since the end of World War II.
Ukraine says it controls about 100 border settlements over an area of about 1,000 sq. km -- a humiliation for President Vladimir Putin.
Information from the area is minimal because of a lack of access.
Tens of thousands of civilians fled at the start of the incursion, the Kremlin claims. The number who remained has not been made public.
"Several thousand" Russian civilians are still there, said Oleksiy Dmytrashkivsky, spokesman for Ukraine's military administration in Kursk province.
Living conditions are difficult and civilians have to rely on their own reserves and vegetable gardens, or else on the food, water and medicine the Ukrainian military says it is distributing, according to Ukrainian soldiers.
Shops and pharmacies no longer work, electricity and mobile phone networks have been shut down, and Russian forces, who launched a counter-offensive in September, are constantly bombarding the area, said the Ukrainians.
At least 23 civilians have been killed by Russian strikes since the end of August, said Dmytrashkivsky.
AFP was not able to independently verify claims made by the Ukrainian forces or establish how many civilians might have been killed as a result of Ukraine's own shelling.
No resistance
Ukrainian soldiers said they did not encounter resistance from the local population.
"Some of them even greet us in our own language!" said one soldier, Andriy.
In this border region, many residents speak a mix of Russian and Ukrainian.
Andriy said he thought the friendliness might be because of the aid they have received but acknowledged it could also be "because we are armed and people avoid expressing their true feelings."
According to Dmytrashkivsky, Russian civilians were initially "terrified" and "hid" when they saw Ukrainians because of Russian state media narratives.
Now "local residents are not afraid of the Ukrainian army," said another soldier, Sergiy.
"When they see a military vehicle, they come closer; they ask if it is distributing humanitarian aid."
But Sergiy chooses to limit his contact, fearing that anything he says could be passed on to the Russian military.
"A polite and discreet coexistence is enough," he said.
AFP, which has not visited the area of Russia under Ukrainian occupation and cannot speak to civilians who have remained there because of the lack of a phone signal, is unable to confirm the claims made by the Ukrainian military.
Kyiv has invited the United Nations and the International Committee of the Red Cross to visit the area -- an offer the Kremlin denounced as a "pure provocation."
Russia has largely sought to downplay the incursion.
"The situation in the areas controlled by Ukrainian fighters is of course a crisis situation and it will be rectified in good time," Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said on September 20 in answer to a question from AFP.
Russian Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Maria Zakharova has accused Ukraine of setting up "concentration camps" in the area.
But Peskov said there was "no information" to back up this claim.
Counter-propaganda
Dmytrashkivsky admitted he had wanted to be "rude" with Russian civilians when he arrived because of the suffering inflicted by Moscow's troops on Ukraine.
Now, he said, "I just feel sorry for these people" who "have been brainwashed."
"They're peaceful people who aren't prone to conflict," said Sergiy.
He said the locals "don't provoke any aggression from us," having "found themselves in this ambiguous situation" through no fault of their own.
Dmytrashkivsky has decided to mount a counter-propaganda effort "for educational purposes" to show Russian civilians the alleged atrocities committed by the Russian army in Ukraine.
With his laptop, he goes from house to house to show a war news bulletin, specially produced in Russian, and a documentary about Bucha, a town near Kyiv where the Russian army is accused of massacring hundreds of civilians in spring 2022.
He also wants to start a small newspaper to be distributed to local residents, called the "Wind of Kursk."